What this code requires
CRC R319.2 sets the minimum dimensions for emergency escape and rescue openings (EEROs) in sleeping rooms and basements. The net clear opening must be at least 5.7 square feet (5.0 sq ft for grade-floor or below-grade openings), with a minimum clear height of 24 inches and a minimum clear width of 20 inches. The finished sill height can't exceed 44 inches above the floor. These numbers tell you exactly how big a bedroom window has to be so a firefighter can climb in or an occupant can climb out without a ladder or assistance.
How to fix it
Pull the window schedule and mark every EERO
Go through the window schedule and identify every window serving a sleeping room or basement. Mark each one as an EERO and note its rough opening size, frame type (single-hung, casement, slider), and operating sash dimensions. Don't confuse nominal window size with net clear opening. Net clear opening is measured from the inside of the frame with the sash fully open, not the rough or frame opening. If the schedule doesn't currently show those fields, add columns for them now.
Calculate net clear opening for each EERO
For each marked window, multiply the net clear height (sash travel at full open) by the net clear width. The result must be at least 5.7 square feet, or 5.0 sq ft for a grade-floor opening (bottom of the clear opening not more than 44 inches above or below the adjacent finished grade). Check both: the area AND each linear dimension independently. Minimum clear height is 24 inches. Minimum clear width is 20 inches. A window can meet the area floor and still fail if either dimension is short. Manufacturer product data sheets list net clear opening for each operator type.
Verify finished sill height at each EERO location
Measure from the finished floor to the top of the window sill at each EERO location. The maximum is 44 inches. If any window sits above a raised platform, closet floor, or knee wall, measure from the actual finished floor level of the room, not from the rough framing. Note the floor-to-sill dimension on the floor plan or window schedule. For windows near the 44-inch limit, an explicit dimension note prevents the checker from flagging it.
Add net clear opening dimensions to the window schedule
The window schedule needs to show net clear height, net clear width, and net clear area for every EERO, not just the nominal window size. Add three columns or a callout note. If you're using a manufacturer's window, the product spec sheet lists the net clear opening for each operator type. A double-hung window and a casement of the same nominal size have different net clear openings, so note the operator type too. This documentation removes any ambiguity for the plan-checker.
Flag grade-floor openings and call out the 5.0 sq ft exception
If the bottom of the clear opening is not more than 44 inches above or below the finished grade outside, it is a grade-floor opening and the minimum area drops to 5.0 square feet. Note the exception directly on the window schedule or plan sheet next to the window tag. Write something like: 'Window [X] is a grade-floor EERO. Min. net clear area: 5.0 sq ft per CRC R319.2.1 exception.' This tells the plan-checker exactly what you're relying on. Without the note, a checker who doesn't verify the sill height above grade will flag a 5.2-square-foot window as non-compliant.
Revise the window sizing if any opening is undersized
If a window doesn't meet the minimum dimensions, your options are: (a) swap to a larger window unit that clears 5.7 sq ft, 24 inches height, and 20 inches width; (b) change the operator type if the frame is acceptable but the sash travel is the problem, such as switching a fixed-over-operable single-hung to a full-casement; or (c) add a second EERO if the room layout allows. Document the change on the plans with the revised net clear dimensions and confirm the sill height still meets the 44-inch cap after the swap.
Show a detail or schedule note for the 44-inch sill cap
If any EERO sill is between 36 and 44 inches, note it explicitly. Write the finished-floor-to-sill dimension on the floor plan next to the window tag. Some plan-checkers will flag anything near 44 inches without a documented measurement because they can't verify it from the drawings alone. One clear dimension note avoids a back-and-forth correction cycle.
Cross-check bedroom count and window locations before resubmitting
Every room labeled 'bedroom,' 'sleeping room,' or any room that could function as a bedroom needs a compliant EERO. In ADU projects, flex rooms and study alcoves with closets often get classified as bedrooms during plan review even if the drawings don't call them that. Walk the floor plan and count every potential sleeping space. Also confirm that any window well serving a below-grade EERO meets the clear dimensions in CRC R319.4 before you resubmit, so you don't fix the window and get a second correction on the well.
Take the CRC R319.2 fix steps with you
All 8 steps in one email, so you have them on site instead of on this page.
Why you got flagged
Most corrections citing R319.2 come down to one of three problems on the window schedule or the floor plan.
The first is a window that meets the area requirement but fails one of the linear dimensions. A 36-inch-wide by 24-inch-tall window has a net clear opening of 6.0 square feet, which passes the area test. But if the installer uses a single-hung window and the operable sash only opens to 18 inches of clear height, the 24-inch minimum isn't met and the window fails. Plan-checkers flag this when the window schedule lists nominal size without showing the net clear opening dimensions.
The second problem is a sill height that wasn't checked against the 44-inch cap. A bedroom window installed above a closet shelf or a high knee wall puts the sill at 48 or 50 inches. That's a common layout in split-level additions where the floor drops. The plan shows the window location but doesn't note the finished floor-to-sill measurement, so the checker has to flag it for clarification.
The third scenario is a basement or ground-floor bedroom where the area requirement drops to 5.0 square feet. Some designers apply the 5.7-square-foot standard to every opening. A grade-floor bedroom window sized to exactly 5.2 square feet passes the exception but fails the general rule, and if the plans don't call out the grade-floor exception, a plan-checker reading fast will flag it as undersized.
The official code
California Building Standards Code, Title 24 Part 2.5 — California Residential Code (BSC)
Read the source →